i have a woody magnum that is about a year old and the bands are still in good shape but im having a problem getting it to stick in fish lately. i have shot plenty of thick skinned fish (cobia, spade fish etc) but lately i have had a lot of fish come off. i am shooting a break away and i just shot a large trigger fish and grouper that the point didnt stick to only one flopper is making it in the fish. was considering going up to a stronger band. any advice would be helpful.
Not sure what you mean by “thin skinned” and “thick skinned” fish, but from my experience, if you can stick a cobia, you can stick any fish on the rigs. I can stick a spade fish with my knife, and triggers are slow and dumb. Groupers and cobia are a different story, however. I use a gulf magnum xhd, 4'' slip tip, a 3/8'' shaft, and 3x#424 bands, and that knocks through any fish i can find in the gulf. My advice: lose the floppers, and get a gun that can handle the larger bands…
Not sure how often you shoot the gun but if the bands are a year old they probably need changing. They may look fine (i.e. not dry rotted) but to me i find they are noticeably loosing their snap about 6-8 dive trips (thats about 30-50 shots the way I dive). Even a year old gun could have sat on someones shelf for a few years prior to purchase and the bands are that much further weakened.
I time my band changes so that I start with fresh rubber at the beginning of each season and usually change em out once again mid season. I keep a few of the old bands on the boat or in the bag as spares (in case I break or damage a fresh one).
In between trips I keep them in the freezer…it really does seem to make a difference. If you dont dive that much and keep the bands stored out of the sun and heat you may get more mileage than me. Fresh bands are cheap enough insurance that I try to change them 2x a year, but once a year is the bare minimum.